Firefly and PC GAMESS-related discussion club

Learn how to ask questions correctly  
We are NATO-free zone

Re: Is there any practical use of orbitals generated with NBO module?


Dear colleagues, please disregard this nbo failure claim for a while as the statistics might be a result of incorrect orbital arrangement. I will update this topic later after fixing the problem.

On Sat Sep 27 '14 3:18am, alex wrote
>Hi Qchemists,
>I have some concerns about nbo module of firefly. The problem is that nbo’s starting orbitals doesn’t converge with mcscf functions. I did dozen of tests with my problem (CASSCF(6,7), NSTATE=2) and get neither converged after 2048 SCF steps if started from nbo guesses. I know about ‘look into orbitals’ and ’look again‘, but... The use of ‘MCSF optimized orbitals’ from that unconverged ffly runs resulted in perfect convergence (after less than 100 steps for 2 systems which I’ve tried)! Evidently my understanding of the chemical problem haven’t changed and I’ve selected active space in the same way (as far as it is possible). So the question is how to use nbo module for mcscf? Maybe one should pick some ‘wasted’ orbitals in addition to the active space to make nbo converging? Or maybe there is a need for preprocessing to convert nbo orbitals into something really useful?
>Thanks for sharing your experience,

[ Previous ] [ Next ] [ Index ]           Sun Sep 28 '14 0:27am
[ Reply ] [ Edit ] [ Delete ]           This message read 394 times